by Maureen Crawford Hentz
The most important rule in writing letters of recommendation is to just say no
if you can't write a glowing letter. It is difficult to say no to an eager job-searcher and
will require all of your best assertiveness skills, but it is better for the searcher to know
that you can't effectively endorse him/her. If you can't write a glowing letter because
the person's performance has been less than stellar, it's important for him or her to
know.You can break the news in this way: "John, I don't think that I am the best
person to be a reference for you at this time. Have you thought of someone else
you can use?"
Most important is to understand what aspects of the candidate you should highlight,
which is best done in conversation with the candidate. Great references include
specific information related both to the position and to the candidate's extant skills.
For graduate school, focus not only on potential contributions to the future field,
but those the candidate can make in the classroom community as well.
Find out if the letter should be a general one or for a specific position. Ideally,
with some addition of specifics, the general letter can be used for a position-specific
recommendation later.
For position-specific letters of recommendation (or phone references), ask the
candidate for a job description of the position for which they are applying. In
this way, you can include some specific details about how the candidate would
be a good fit.
The letter is not about you. A brief mention of your relationship to the applicant is
all the information about you that is necessary in the letter.
Truly great letters of recommendation feature the candidate's knowledge, skills
and attitude. In addition, stellar letters seek to distinguish a candidate from the pool.
Phrases like "the strongest intern I've supervised in 10 years of professional
practice" and "one of the top 10 staff members with whom I worked" distinguish
your candidate.
Include contact information. At the end of the letter, include email and phone
information in case the hiring committee needs additional information. End with
a restatement of your endorsement of the candidate. A strong way to close
would be "I highly recommend Mark for admission to your program. I have
no doubt that he will be an outstanding lawyer, and I look forward to her
contributions in our profession."
For general letters of recommendation or letters for an applicant's file, give the
candidate one copy of the letter and one copy of the letter in a signed, sealed
envelope. Many grant/fellowship/graduate school applications require this kind
of letter.
Questions about some of the terminology used in this article? Get more information (definitions and links) on key college, career, and job-search
terms by going to our Job-Seeker's Glossary of Job-Hunting Terms.
QuintZine regular contributor Maureen Crawford Hentz is the director
of career services at Wentworth Institute of Technology, Boston. An independent
career and HR consultant she has been working with career-seekers for 10 years.
She has a master's degree in college student personnel from Bowling Green State
University. A popular conference lecturer, she specializes in large and small
specially designed workshops for professional organizations, students and
environmental groups. Her most popular career workshops address topics
including: Non-Verbal Techniques To Use During an Interview; Powerful
Resumes; and Interviewing Etiquette You've Never Even Thought About.
She has a particular interest in job-searching techniques for differently-abled
candidates, new grads, and career changers.
Go to the Job
References & Portfolio Services section of Quintessential Careers.