by Randall S. Hansen, Ph.D.
There's sometimes a point in career planning when people are discouraged
from following their dreams because their career choice does not fit in with
traditional gender roles. Men are discouraged from careers in nursing, social
work, and teaching while women are discouraged from careers in technology,
science, and security. Men who are interested in "feminine" jobs are teased
about their sexuality and women who are interested in "male" jobs are
questioned as to whether they have the brains or stamina to perform.
Given all these issues, its imperative in career planning that people --
regardless of their gender -- are allowed to follow their dreams and utilize their
interests and skills. Career planning should not be about gender stereotyping.
And the good news is that research shows that men and women are
increasingly moving into -- and succeeding in -- non-traditional careers.
Still, there are quite a few careers for both men and women that can be
listed as non-traditional. Non-traditional careers are ones those in which
fewer than 25 percent of the workforce is of one gender.
(See
our list of non-traditional careers for men and women.)
However, job-seekers considering a non-traditional career path should weigh
the pros and cons before making a final decision about whether to pursue this path.
Pros of Non-Traditional Careers
The biggest pro of working in a non-traditional career is the intrinsic benefit
of following your dreams and the satisfaction that comes from the
empowerment of a job done well.
One of the other big pros -- but also potentially one of the biggest cons -- is
that people in non-traditional jobs will receive more attention. If you are doing
well, that attention is generally good because all workers want to be
recognized for their hard work (although the attention could raise jealousy
issues among co-workers), but if you are struggling a bit, that attention will
simply amplify the problems and add to the pressure to perform.
Another pro of non-traditional careers is their impact on society. No one
gender has a lock on any occupation, and workers who are some of the
first of their gender to succeed in a career open the door to others.
For women, another pro is that the pay is typically much higher in careers
where men dominate; thus, you'll have the potential to make more money
in a non-traditional career.
For men, another pro is that you are often given positions of responsibility
sooner, because, fairly or not, men are often seen as having natural leadership
and other key skills.
Cons of Non-Traditional Careers
Probably the biggest con is the lack of enough mentors in non-traditional
careers. Mentors, people in higher positions within your career field, are
critical to your success as they can guide you, protect you, and help you
along in your career.
(Read more
about mentors.)
Another con is the potential negative feelings from co-workers, especially
for female workers in a traditionally male career. You can be seen as taking
the "spot" reserved for a friend, or worse, a token worker hired to avoid
lawsuits or appease special-interest groups. And in the worst case
scenario, these negative feelings can lead to sexual harassment.
Amazingly, another con is the potential to have little or no support from
family and friends who may question your motives for entering a more
challenging career -- or who simply don't understand the pressures and
problems you face in a non-traditional career.
Finally, in certain traditionally male careers, the physical part of the job
can be very demanding, so a final con for women is that some non-traditional
careers impose both mental and physical challenges that may be overwhelming.
Final Thoughts
If you are considering a non-traditional career, perhaps the best way to
determine whether you really want to purse the career is to gather as
much information as possible -- and gain experience wherever possible.
Consider informational interviews and job shadowing with people of your
own sex who are successful in their careers; it's through these activities
that you can learn more about their joys and frustrations and see
first-hand what a career might be like for you. And, of course, you
should also gain experience in your career through internships,
volunteering, or part-time employment.
Questions about some of the terminology used in this article? Get more information (definitions and links) on key college, career, and job-search
terms by going to our Job-Seeker's Glossary of Job-Hunting Terms.
Dr. Randall S. Hansen is founder of Quintessential Careers,
one of the oldest and most comprehensive career development sites on the Web, as well CEO of
EmpoweringSites.com. He is also founder of
MyCollegeSuccessStory.com and
EnhanceMyVocabulary.com. He is publisher of
Quintessential Careers Press,
including the Quintessential Careers electronic newsletter,
QuintZine. Dr. Hansen is also a
published author, with several books, chapters in books, and hundreds of articles. He's often
quoted in the media and conducts empowering workshops around the country. Finally, Dr. Hansen is
also an educator, having taught at the college level for more than 15 years. Visit his
personal Website or
reach him by email at randall(at)quintcareers.com.